…you might get something very similar to the CW’s new Arrow. It’s not surprising that the new show should take a similar path. Christopher Nolan’s interpretation of Batman was hugely successful, both critically, and financially. Batman, the Frank Miller inspired version; the obsessed, little-bit psychotic vigilante, fighting his own demons as much as bad guys, translated well onto the screen. So if you were looking for another DC superhero property to give the same treatment to, there probably isn’t a better choice than the Green Arrow.
The show looks good on the screen, although the foyer of the Queen mansion looks suspiciously like the one in Lex Luthor’s transplanted castle in Smallville. As much as I enjoy the miracle of CGI and its ability to bring anything that you can imagine to the screen, there is nothing like good old fashioned stunts. The pilot has lead actor Stephen Amell demonstrating some fairly impressive parkour skills and in fact Amell did train in parkour to prepare for this role, although many of the stunts are done by stunt doubles. It’s a smooth enough transition that I can’t tell the difference though. I was watching and it looked like Amell did all of the parkour stunts.
As originally portrayed in the comics, Oliver Queen was a millionaire playboy who also dabbled in crime fighting as the Green Arrow. He was an expert archer, acquiring those skills while stranded on an island. His stock in trade was trick arrows that could perform assorted functions. He was Batman, without the compelling reason to be a Batman. Eventually the comics provided a reason, having Queen lose his fortune and discovering the living is a lot harder without lots of money to fall back on. Green Arrow becomes a crusader for social justice as well as the old fashioned kind.
In Arrow, the CW takes those basics and tries to re-imagine a much grittier, edgier version; a Green Arrow to match the edgier Dark Knight version of Batman. As the pilot episode opens, Oliver Queen is rescued from his island prison after being missing and presumed dead for 5 years. However this Oliver has a specific agenda, that’s partially revealed in flashbacks to the sinking of his yacht and the death of his father. If you’ve not seen pilot, I won’t spoil it other than to say the death of his father gives him a very specific list of wrongs to be righted.
This Oliver Queen is rather morally ambiguous. Is he a good guy? It’s not so clear cut, and it looks like the show intends to draw that out. The outing he was on when his yacht sank has him bringing along his then current girlfriend’s sister for a little cheat-o-rama. That girlfriend, Laurel Lance, despises him for her sister’s death although their futures may be linked since careful comic book readers will note that Laurel Lance is the future Black Canary, Green Arrow’s long time girlfriend in the comics. But cheating on a girlfriend isn’t that edgy or gritty; killing a kidnapper who is helpless is.
In most superhero sagas, guns are never used and killing is strictly forbidden. However for this show, we have a superhero that does kill, not in self defense, but to protect his secrets. That ups the ante in the gritty and edgy department. Without the normal limitations of the superhero genre, who knows where this show will go?
Weaved into the plot is more potential “drama” than you can shake a stick at. His kid sister is using drugs, there is a new stepfather, and mommy dearest isn’t exactly the June Cleaver type; she has secrets of her own. Not to mention the local police detective is the father of both Laurel Lance and the sister who died when the Queen yacht sank. Guess who he blames for his daughter’s death?
And for that, I’m enthusiastic about this take on the Green Arrow story. Yes, I realize there is the potential to go too far; turning this version of Green Arrow from less like an edgy Batman and more like a rich Dexter. That would be a mistake, and hopefully the producers will put the brakes on any mass murder spree by a DC superhero.
Still, I like what I see so far and am willing to give this show some long rope to see where it goes.