I noticed on a message board today a liberal was making a loaded comment (is there any other kind?) about this election being about two differing views of immigration. One view is that this country belongs to the white Christians who founded the country, and the other view that the country’s founding was on Universalist principles open to everyone. Naturally it was a false choice between racism and open borders, but I took the bait and responded anyway:
I would agree that this election does waiver between two competing views of immigration, although perhaps not exactly in the way you have framed.
1. There are those who believe that there is a particular American culture, with a particular history, and want new immigrants to assimilate into that culture. American history has taught us that doesn’t happen when there is a constant flow of co-ethnics pouring into the country, reinforcing old world manners, culture, and language. Germans ( the original poster used the example of Germans who were thought to unassimilatable at the nation’s founding), who meet your definition of being white and Christian and were established in the country from before the revolution, didn’t fully assimilate until after World War 1, and that was primarily because of severe anti German feeling at the time. Real assimilation happened after immigration was sharply reduced in the 1920’s and kept that way until the 1960’s.
2. There are other people who don’t think there is a distinct American culture or cultural and political history, or if there is, it’s distasteful and should be eliminated. Their definition of American includes the entire world and any culture, no matter how savage or backward. They believe that whatever views occupy the zeitgeist at any particular time are universal values that everyone shares, even if they don’t know it. They don’t believe that different cultures often have ways that may be offensive to other cultures, and if they do, heh, it all comes out in the wash. They believe every community should be overwritten by another community constantly; ideas like home and hearth are offensive.
I think the real difference in this election is between:
1. Those who want immigration to serve the interests of the people of the country.
2. Those who want immigration to serve the interest of non Americans, politicians, and labor intensive corporations.
That’s the real difference, and the election gives a clear choice on that.
Naturally he called me a racist.