The worst-case scenario actually became…the scenario.
As I wrote at the outset of the war, I was a skeptic of this action and did not see any imminent threat that would require such an action. I still don’t. Still, I thought, Trump has pulled off some successful military operations, including Operation Midnight Hammer that was supposed to take care of one of the reasons we went to war in the first place, eliminating the nuclear threat from Iran. So maybe he knew what he was doing.
Narrator: He did not.
It’s not just that the war went on longer than predicted, it’s that under the original war aim, we failed. Trump’s original goals were obliterating Iran’s missile capabilities, annihilating its navy, ensuring it never acquires a nuclear weapon, and severing its support for terrorist proxies. Of those, the only one we accomplished was destroying its navy, and that didn’t stop the Iranians from being able to shut off the Strait to commercial traffic.
And of course, when the much-lauded Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) came out, providing a cease fire, I couldn’t believe it; it read like a surrender document; ours. Just to summarize quickly the worse points of agreement:
4)” … Immediately upon the signing of this MOU, the United States of America will begin the removal of its naval blockade and any disturbances or impediments against the Islamic Republic of Iran and will fully end the naval blockade within 30 days. During this period, the traffic of vessels will be in proportion to the numbers of pre-war traffic being restored by the Islamic Republic of Iran. The United States of America further undertakes to remove its forces from the proximity of the Islamic Republic of Iran within 30 days after the final deal.”
So, we’re leaving regardless.
5) “Upon the signing of this MOU, the Islamic Republic of Iran will make arrangements using its best efforts for the safe passage of commercial vessels with no charge, for 60 days only, from the Persian Gulf to the Sea of Oman and vice versa. The traffic of commercial vessels will immediately start and considering the need for removing the technical and military obstacles, and demining by the Islamic Republic of Iran will be instated within 30 days. The Islamic Republic of Iran will conduct dialog with the Sultanate of Oman to define the future administration and maritime services in the Strait of Hormuz in discussion with other Persian Gulf littoral states in line with the applicable international law and the sovereign rights of coastal states of the Strait of Hormuz.”
This must be worst part of the MOU. We are legitimizing Iran’s control of the Strait of Hormuz. After the 60 days, they can…do what ever they want? Charge big bucks for every ship crossing the strait? This will create a very bad precedent for the world and international trade in general. If allowed to stand, the war will leave the world in a much worse place than before the war, and grant terrorist state Iran a massive financial boon.
6) “The United States of America undertakes with regional partners to develop a definitive, mutually agreed plan with at least USD 300 billion for the reconstruction and economic development of the Islamic Republic of Iran. The mechanism for the implementation of this plan will be finalized as part of a final deal within 60 days. All required licenses, waivers and permissions needed for the relevant financial transactions will be granted by the United States of America.”
Yes, I know, we’re not actually ponying up the 300 billion, but we are allowing and facilitating it. Before this, Iran was totally cut off from the international banking system. Now it will have access to credit. That’s a lot of weapons it can buy for its terrorist proxy groups.
7) “The United States of America undertakes to terminate all types of sanctions against the Islamic Republic of Iran, including the United Nations Security Council resolutions, IAEA Board of Governors resolutions, and all unilateral US sanctions, primary and secondary, in an agreed upon schedule as part of the final deal.”
Sanctions relief too. Obama couldn’t have given away this much to Iran as Trump is trying to do.
8) “The Islamic Republic of Iran reaffirms that it shall not procure or develop nuclear weapons. The United States of America and the Islamic Republic of Iran have agreed to resolve the disposition of stockpiled enriched material pursuant to a mechanism that will be mutually agreed upon in accordance with the schedule mentioned in paragraph seven, with the minimum methodology to be down blended on site under the supervision of the IAEA.”
Big deal. Iran has been promising to not develop nuclear weapons for as long as they’ve been attempting to develop nuclear weapons. And the “down blended” enriched uranium will never happen. That will be so far in the future that when Iran reneges, it will barely warrant a news article here, and of course there is no enforcement mechanism.
10) “The United States of America undertakes that immediately upon the signing of this MOU and until the termination of sanctions, US Department of Treasury will issue waivers for the export of Iranian crude oil, petroleum products and derivatives, and all associated services, including banking transactions, insurances, transportation, etc.”
Yes, we’re helping Iran get back in the oil business allowing Iran to export oil legally to whoever it wants.
11) “The United States of America undertakes to make fully available for use the frozen or restricted funds and assets of the Islamic Republic of Iran upon the implementation of this MOU. The United States of America and the Islamic Republic of Iran will mutually agree on the procedures related to the release of these funds during negotiations. Such funds, whether retained in the original account or transferred, shall be made fully usable for payment to any ultimate beneficiary designated by the Central Bank of the Islamic Republic of Iran. The United States of America undertakes to issue all necessary licenses and authorizations accordingly.”
This reads to me that Iran gets all its frozen funds back, some of which has been frozen since the hostage crisis.
So, what did the US get out of this?
A humiliating defeat. Not on the battlefield, but the US is continuing its long experience with winning all the battles and losing the war. And now, the threat of US military action against Iran is no longer much of a threat. We gave it our best shot, and the regime survived. Do you think they care a lot less about Trump threats of more bombs now than they did before the war started? I think we know the answer.
How did we get here?
Based on the news reporting I read from The New York Times and others, early on Trump dismissed the regime change aspect of the military campaign, but the problem is, nothing about the war was going to work without it. There was never going to be a “deal” with the current Iranian regime. They are fanatics who can’t be dissuaded from their goals and use negotiations as merely time buying exercises. That’s been the entire history of Iranian “negotiations” for the past 47 years. Trump felt he could negotiate anything, but he can’t; not this. And unless we are willing to go total war with Iran, meaning a full mobilization and a ground war to fight for territory inch by inch, the regime was not going to be overthrown.
So, the war may not quite be over, but it’s over enough to know we lost. No final agreement coming out of the MOU is going to be better than what we have, and it’s not a good agreement; it’s a surrender.